A question often pondered by homeowners when they notice their windows not performing as advertised. Most people, by default, would simply opt for replacements… but they're expensive, and the costs add up quickly when replacing multiple windows. Sometimes, repairing them is the way to go. However, how can a layman determine which option is right for them? Let's find out.

Factor To Consider

Money isn't the only factor to consider here, though it is arguably the most important one. However, many times, windows don't particularly need to be replaced. It makes no sense to dump your current car and get a new one just because a window was broken, no pun intended. Here are some other factors that you must keep in mind when choosing between the two:

Age of Your Windows

Windows that have served for over 15 years may have degraded to the point where they're prone to issues and nearing the end of their lifespan. At that stage, opting for a window replacement service would be a smart long-term decision.

Extent of Damage

Some damage is beyond repair and simply calls for a replacement. Large cracks longer than a few inches tend to spread over time, and cracks reaching the edge, for example, are particularly dangerous as they can compromise the entire windowpane.

However, issues like air leaks and minor water leaks can still be fixed by a professional, as they have some scope for repairability.

As a general rule of thumb, consider the severity of the damage:

Minor damage (tiny cracks, faulty hardware, chipped paint)? Repair away.

Major damage (rotting frames, significant glass cracks, or condensation between panes)? Time for a replacement.

Cost of Repairs vs. Replacement

While we've mentioned that cost isn't the only factor, it can't be ignored. If repairs are frequent, the smarter investment in the long run is simply replacing the windows. However, if a repair job costs less than 30% of the replacement cost and fully resolves the issue, repair may be the better choice. A professional window replacement service can assess the damage and help determine the most cost-effective option.

Home Value & Aesthetic Appeal

Aesthetics do count, and while they shouldn't come at the cost of a compromised window, they shouldn't be completely ignored either. Some older windows have a charm to them, and if repairs can preserve that charm, they're absolutely worth the effort. However, if you're planning to give your home a fresh new look—and boost its resale value—replacing the windows could provide a solid return on investment.

Safety & Security Concerns

As we just stated, aesthetics absolutely matter, but safety comes first. If your windows don't lock properly or the glass is cracking, they're a security risk. A single pigeon that's lost its way could shatter cracked glass. Modern windows offer stronger glass, reinforced locks, and shatter-resistant technology, making replacement the safer choice.

Time & Convenience

Sometimes, you just need a quick fix. While quick fixes aren't always the safest approach when it comes to something as integral to a home's security as windows, they may be necessary in the short term. Repairs are the easiest short-term solution. However, once time isn't a major constraint, hire a professional window replacement service to ensure your windows remain safe and functional in the long run.

Conclusion

Long story short, the choice between repairing and replacing windows largely depends on the condition of your windows and your circumstances as a homeowner. Minor issues such as small cracks, minor water or air leakage, sound issues, or single-pane windows can often be repaired. However, if there are structural problems, major water leakage, massive drafts, or damaged muntins—and cost and time aren't major concerns—replacement should be preferred. For window installations, it's best to trust professionals, as DIYing it can end up doing more harm than good.